Spotting a Predatory Lender Before You Sign
Six warning signs that the loan is the trap, not the solution.
Predatory lending is a multibillion-dollar industry built on people in desperate situations. The products are designed to keep you borrowing - not to solve your problem. Here are six warning signs that the "help" you are being offered is actually the trap.
1. Triple-digit APR
If a loan has an annual percentage rate above 36%, it is almost certainly a predatory product. Payday loans regularly run 300-700% APR. Title loans and "no credit check" installment loans often top 100%. These rates are not legal in some states, but they are legal in many.
2. No credit check required
A legitimate lender wants to know if you can pay them back. A predatory lender does not, because their business model assumes you cannot - and that you will roll the loan over indefinitely. "No credit check" almost always means "extremely high APR to compensate."
3. Pressure to roll over
Payday lenders make their money when you cannot pay the loan back at the end of two weeks and have to "renew" or "rollover." Each rollover adds new fees. The CFPB found that the average payday borrower took out 10 loans a year and spent more in fees than they originally borrowed.
4. Collateral that is the value at stake
Title loans use your car as collateral. Pawn loans use whatever you brought in. If you cannot pay, you lose the asset. A few hundred dollars in cash for a $5,000 car is a transfer of value, not a loan.
5. Vague total cost
If you cannot easily get a clear answer to "what is the total dollar cost of this loan if I pay it back as scheduled," walk away. Reputable lenders state APR and total cost up front in plain numbers. Predatory lenders bury them in fine print.
6. Solicitation when you are at your lowest
Predatory lenders advertise in communities under financial stress, target people with recent bankruptcies, and offer "debt consolidation" that bundles unsecured debt into secured debt (with your house as collateral). Anyone who shows up unsolicited offering a quick fix should be treated as a threat, not a helper.
Better options for emergencies
- Credit union "payday alternative loans." Federally capped at 28% APR, available at most credit unions for members.
- Employer paycheck advance. Many employers offer interest-free advances on earned wages.
- Local nonprofits and 211. United Way's 211 hotline can connect you to emergency assistance for rent, utilities, food.
- Negotiating directly with the creditor. Many companies have hardship programs they do not advertise.
If you are caught in one
Report predatory lenders to the CFPB at consumerfinance.gov/complaint. The CFPB will mediate. Many states have additional consumer protection offices. You are not powerless, even if the contract makes it feel that way.
Tip a story
Spot an error or have a topic you want us to cover? Email editorial@themoneyzone.org. We read everything.
More from Loans
Personal Loans 101: When They Make Sense, When They Do Not
Cheaper than credit cards, more dangerous than a budget. Use them on purpose.
Student Loan Repayment Plans Compared
Standard, graduated, income-driven - which one actually saves you money.